Bungled batts would 'scare' public

The number of homes found with unsafe insulation from the federal government's
bungled scheme will be kept secret because it would scare the public and ruin fraud
investigations, the responsible bureaucrat has argued.
The government on Monday released an update on its progress to wind down the $2.45
billion home insulation scheme.
An auditor-general's report last week found safety practices were overlooked in the
Environment Department's rush to roll it out.
Four deaths and hundreds of fires have been linked to the program, with more than
4000 cases of potential fraud identified.
It has left homeowners fearful of fire hazards in their roofs as well as "live"
ceilings caused by foil insulation touching electric wires.
The government has either completed or arranged times to inspect about 55,000
non-foil installations and will finish inspecting foil insulation jobs by Christmas.
Climate Change Minister Greg Combet and his parliamentary secretary, Mark Dreyfus,
said the CSIRO and an independent consultant would be commissioned to analyse the
inspection data and publicly release the results.
But data on inspections to date won't be released as it would be skewed, as they
target work by businesses linked to the fires.
Climate Change Department deputy secretary Martin Bowles was forced to defend the
decision in a senate estimates hearing on Monday.
Mr Bowles said data on the foil inspections was being provided to the department and
he believed "the overwhelming majority" of work was problem-free.
Releasing the information could compromise future fraud inquiries, he argued.
"It can create apprehension in the broader community and it can further do damage to
the industry if, in fact, inappropriately that kind of information is out in the
public arena," Mr Bowles said.
"If in fact they are fraudulent and I start to release the information out there ...
it scares the horses."
Liberal senator Simon Birmingham was "gobsmacked" Mr Bowles hadn't brought the data,
compiled by consultants PwC, to the hearing.
The numbers could be released without risking the success of future fraud
investigations, he said.
"I find it astounding that in the thick folder of briefings before you, you don't
have any briefings that give us any other feedback about what these inspections have
found," Senator Birmingham said.
Mr Bowles said he deemed the "appropriate" statistics to release were those in Mr
Combet's media release.
It said more than 50,000 homeowners who received foil insulation had been offered a
choice, based on an electrician's advice, to have it removed or safety switches
installed.
Of the 17,000 who sought advice, 46 per cent opted to have the foil removed and 40
per cent had safety switches installed.
Only 14 per cent have had inspections, as of last Friday.
The insulation industry assistance package, to support reputable home ceiling
insulation businesses left with excess insulation stock after the program was
terminated, has received 941 applications.
So far 631 have been approved, worth $21.7 million.



------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This email is intended for the use of the addressee only. If you receive this email
in error, please delete it immediately. This email may contain information which is
confidential and/or legally privileged. You must not use or disclose the contents of
this email, or add the sender's email address to any database, list or mailing list
unless you are expressly authorised to do so. The statements or views expressed in
this email are those of the individual sender and are not those of Australian
Associated Press Pty Ltd (AAP). These statements are not binding on AAP, except
where the sender expressly and with authority, states them to be. AAP is unable to
review the contents of all the email on its system. To the extent permitted by law,
AAP disclaims all liability for any loss or damage caused by the contents of this
email. www.aap.com.au